Updated: Nov 15/26

Lossless encoders

Most compression smallest filesize first

  1. Lossless Audio Info and download, Windows, OS/2 Odin compatible and Linux, least player support best for archive, 2 Gui Windows apps, player plugins Win/Lin
    Alternate download Rarewares || Original site
  2. OptimFrog slowest, more players
  3. Monkey's audio much quicker than above, use setting: Extra High, good player support, most pleasant sound with very small file size.
    Unix port || At Sourceforge
  4. Tak very fast, just behind Monkey in size, limited players, any Ffmpeg based will play, source included, Winamp plugin. Impressive! Combined with LossyWav creates lossless file same or smaller than Mp3 320.

Quick encoding

  1. True Audio TTA good for multi-channel audio, similar file size to Flac exceptionally quick, compress only no stream modify || Sourceforge dl WLM os, plugins
  2. Tak - Tom's Audio Kompressor see above
  3. Flac Larger file size
  4. WavPack lossy, lossless or hybrid (small play file with correction file large)
    Rarewares download Win/Lin, Flac and others

Other lossless

  1. Halac multi-thread encoder should be super fast. Requires files from Itunes to function. Little player support, new codec.
  2. WMA lossless encoder only Written outside of Microsoft, command line. Creates largest file size, nothing special to use for.
  3. Other: SAC ultimate compressor for size, take nap when encoding though. Purely theoretical at present. Mpeg4-ALS where is executable? No special feature. Hardly used. Alac Apple only, large file size. Apple must have it's own version, unneeded.

Lossy encoders by preference

  1. Musepack MPC, most musically balanced lossy compared. Best quality, eliminated playing lossless files for this. Small file size. || Gui for MPC
  2. Opus examples similar size to MPC, 63% slower encode uses 48khz, excellent at small bitrates.
    Recommended settings || HydrogenAudio settings
  3. Ogg Vorbis Long time favourite. MPC has better sound/file size, replaced Vorbis for music. For spoken voice, audiobook/interview still great.
  4. AAC at Rarewares Improvement over mp3, MPC still rocks!
    Qaac higher quality need later Windows version || Fraunhofer FDK AAC quality over Faac
  5. Helix mp3 faster than Lame, simple parameters. Helix unix || Helix at Rarewares. Also GoGoNoCoda (lame enhance with assembly code) fast, used GoGo before wiped MP3 from hard drive.
  6. Quite OK Audio Format most simple format, fixed bitrate, very quick decoding.
  7. WMA from Microsoft, no thank you

Myth vs reality

Comments often made on the Web that bitrate equals quality. Which encoder used is more important and most encoders are tuned for specific bitrate range. 224kps for Mp3, Ogg, Aac sufficient, higher rate only adds to file size, little improvement in sound. Vorbis can go as high as 500kbps, yet ideal is 192-224. Musepack at 185 is all you need, Opus at 160 is sweet spot

Flac vs Monkey, Ape encoded with similar compression to Flac is close in speed. Extra compression takes more time. Decompression speed largely irrelavant with today's cpu. Never had an issue with Monkey, it just functions, unlike Flac which caused grief for decades.

Tested songs with Flac, Monkey's Audio, Wavpack and Tak lossless. Using reference player: Ffplay MA had most pleasing sound, WV and Tak in middle, Flac least favorite. Need better than average hardware to notice lossless difference.

Musepack is the favourite, though wanted to give Opus a comparison. Opus slower encode/decode, smaller file size due to Opus at 160, Mpc at 185 nominal. On computers/phones sound difference is blurred between any codec. Play on home system and is noticeable. Opus has neutral sound, balanced throughout frequency range. Like listening to studio monitors in recording studio. Precise analytical neutral. Musepack like at a live performance. Engaged in the music, feel better after. Which is why can listen to Musepack for 3 hours, Opus a half hour is enough. Both were in 432hz pitch, which listening for extended periods has effects such as pain reduction. Musepack moves me, still the King of encoders, Opus is efficient with no specific feeling.

Musepack codec

MusePack (.mpc) is a lossy compressed format considered to be the best of all codecs at moderate to high bitrates. At lower bandwidths of 128 Kbps, any benefits over OGG are less clear. MPC uses subband-based selectable channel coupling, Huffman coding, differential Huffman coding. Typical data rates are between 160 and 200 kbps. Mmuspack encoder uses a frequency range that can reach up to 22KHz. Many people can hear sounds above 16KHz, even when is sometimes difficult to hear sound; improves sound dynamics.
  • Musepack Trac compile tutorial
  • Wiki on format
  • Features

    Opus codec

  • Opus-codec very efficient, fabulous for low bitrate applications

    Encoding desired parameter

  • Musepack 185 kbps: mpcenc --quality 5.35 (add -silent for batch mode, no statistics while encoding)
  • Vorbis 192 kbps: oggenc -q6, for music
  • Vorbis 23 kbps: oggenc -q1.2 --resample 12000 --downmix, (voice only mono for audiobooks or interview)
  • Opus 160 kbps: opusenc --bitrate 160 (music, use much lower for speaking voice only)
  • All are variable bitrate. File size may differ based on composition.

    Organizations

  • Rarewares encoder tools
  • Xiph Foundation developer of Vorbis, Flac, Opus, Speex. Download of tools/players
  • Ogg Vorbis News and info on format
  • Icecast broadcasting system that streams music in Vorbis.
  • Free Software Foundation play Vorbis
  • Hydrogen Wiki
  • Recommended Vorbis encoders

    Comparison of encoding

  • Comparison of decoding times
  • Lossless comparison encoders

    Sound files

  • Freepats system sounds
  • Piano-midi classical
  • Wikimedia midi ebook speech music
  • Wikipedia

    Music streaming

  • Ogg friendly sites
  • Xiph radio list
  • Musicgoal